An aerial view at sunrise of a hilltop hamlet of stone buildings surrounded by forest, with a wide valley and hills stretching to the horizon.
Val d'Orcia, Italy

Monteverdi Tuscany

££££
Grown-up & familyHeritageRustic-luxeArt-filledRecommended

Recommended by friends and by publications we trust. We have not stayed yet; it is high on our list.

Via di Mezzo, Castiglioncello del Trinoro, 53047 Sarteano (SI), ItalyWebsite

An American law professor came to the Val d'Orcia for a birthday and began buying the village; its 14th-century church now has a Fazioli grand piano.

After the Second World War Castiglioncello del Trinoro was all but abandoned, its stone houses and cobbled streets left 786 metres up with almost nobody in them. In 2003 Michael Cioffi, an American law professor, came to the Val d'Orcia for a birthday. From 2005 he was buying the buildings. Ilaria Miani restored them, and the streets still serve as corridors. Indoors the beams are old and the colour is new: one bedroom has a four-poster in lime green and grey-blue on a green floor, with a magenta armchair at its foot. The 14th-century church of Sant'Andrea has new acoustics, a Fazioli grand piano and a concert season that runs from Baroque to jazz. The hotel takes its name from the green mountains and from Claudio Monteverdi, and the church is where it earns the second half.

Recommended for couples who would rather a hilltop with its own concerts than a town, and for families, who are better looked after than the stone suggests: a cot fits in every room category, and some suites take extra beds at no charge. The infinity pool looks out over the valley. The Library Bar looks the other way, across vineyards to Monte Cetona, and pours the aperitivo that goes with it. Dinner is pici all'aglione at Zita, the osteria in the middle of the village, or Oreade, the fine-dining room. Everything else is a drive: about twenty minutes to Montepulciano for wine, half an hour to the hot springs at Bagni San Filippo. The hotel also sponsors an archaeological dig, in case the Middle Ages turn out to be the recent part.

A stone hamlet lit up at night, warm light in the windows and an outdoor dining terrace glowing below, against a deep blue sky.
A bedroom with a lime green and grey four poster frame, a pink armchair, a wood beamed ceiling and a green floor.
An aerial view of a rectangular swimming pool in a garden, a person floating on their back in the water with sun loungers set around the edge.
A table set with a glass of red wine, a glass of water, cutlery and a bowl of cured meat and melon, hills visible beyond a stone wall.
A wrought iron chair and small table with flowers and a drink on a stone terrace, overlooking wooded hills and mountains under a partly clouded sky.
A garden path edged with lavender leading to a stone building with a bell tower, a sun lounger visible in the distance.

The facts

Rooms

Rooms
31
Family rooms
Yes

Room types

  • Village Rooms
  • Village Suites
  • Tuscan View Suites
  • Monte Cetona Suite
  • San Pietro
  • Amiata
  • Muri Antichi

Pools

Pools
1

Food and drink

Restaurants
2
Bars
2
Worth booking
Oreade, the fine-dining restaurant, alongside Zita, the casual osteria in the village centre serving pici all'aglione and carne alla brace
Board
Room and breakfast

Practical

Airport
Florence (FLR), about 1 hour 30 minutes
Beach
No beach nearby
Parking
Yes
Dogs
No
Wifi
Free wifi on site; cellular signal is unreliable off the property given the remote hilltop location.

Building

Architect
Ilaria Miani
Converted
2012

Services

Spa
Yes
Gym
Yes
Yoga
Yes
Shuttle
Yes
Worth knowing
cooking classes, truffle hunting and wine-tasting excursions to Montalcino and Montepulciano, and the concert series in the Chiesa di Sant'Andrea

What's nearby

Sarteano
10 minutes, a drive
Montepulciano
about 20 minutes, a drive
Chiusi-Chianciano Terme station
about 30 minutes, a drive
Bagni San Filippo and San Casciano dei Bagni thermal springs
about 30 minutes, a drive